Thursday, 22 December 2016

Goblin Market – An Erotic Fairy Story

Christina Rossetti Portrait by Dante Gabriel Rossetti
Wikimedia Public Domain

Christina Rossetti was born in London and educated by her mother. Sister of painter and poet, Dante Gabriel Rossetti who was two years her senior, she was fortunate in having a supportive family; her grandfather, impressed by her youthful promise, had collections of poetry printed for her when she was in her early teens, for example: To My Mother on the Anniversary of her birth, April, 27, 1842. The young Christina Rossetti was already deeply religious and her personal convictions had great influence in moulding her poetry. They also affected her love-life, causing the collapse of her engagement to pre-Raphaelite painter, James Collinson.
By the 1880s, after a period of ill-health, Christina Rossetti became an invalid, but continued to write, producing among many other well-known works, the long poem 'Goblin Market', published in 1862.
Critics have construed the poem in many diverse ways; for example, as a warning to young women not to trust strange men, or as a universal lesson to resist the temptations of the flesh. Mackenzie Bell says, in Christina Rossetti, a biographical and critical study, 'I have more than once heard Christina aver that the poem has not any profound or ulterior meaning - it is just a fairy story...'
A woman's sexual fantasy
The conclusion drawn by Cora Kaplan in Sea Changes, Essays on Culture and Feminism is that the poem is a woman's sexual fantasy, and contains elements of masochism, homoeroticism, rape and incest. However, the blurring of the images by use of metaphor, as well as their incompleteness, suggest undertones of repression in Rossetti's psychology. It is particularly relevant when considering she was sexually unitiated and inhibited by the sexual taboos that were endemic in Victorian times.
Kaplan says: 'Most obviously the blurring can be seen as a form of both conscious and unconscious censorship; it is also...the result of sexual ignorance.' According to Kaplan, this combination of sexual rigidity and ignorance contributes to the effects of the poem, which, due to its specific nature and lack of social context, is primarily erotic. Although its beginning engages immediately with its central erotic theme, the poem ends on a social note, for the two girls are married and are mothers.
Biblical Allusions
Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar, in 'The Aesthetics of Renunciation', The Madwoman in the Attic, point out the religious associations and see the poem as rife with Miltonian imagery: 'Certainly, Eve, devouring the garden's intellectual food, acts just like her descendant, Laura.' According to Gilbert, Eve's ultimate goal is equality with, or superiority to, Adam. Likewise, Laura is: '...metaphorically eating words and enjoying the taste of power, just as Eve before her did.' The following lines demonstrate Laura's veritable orgy of greed: 'Then suck'd their fruit globes, fair or red: / Sweeter than honey from the rock, / Stronger than man-rejoicing wine ' / Clearer than water flow'd that juice; / She never tasted such before, / How should it cloy with length of use? / She suck'd and suck'd and suck'd the more.'
Cora Kaplan would not agree tha the poem is a re-enactment of the story of Genesis, or that it is specifically about the fall of Eve. Kaplan explains there is a deliberate contrast between Rossetti's poem and the myth of Eve's succumbing to temptation in Eden: 'While the snake's apple produced sensations of shame in the Edenic couple, the goblins' fruit gives Laura knowledge of desire but not shame.'
Gilbert and Gubar claim that 'Goblin Market' depicts alternative possibilities for women, for Laura dares to be disobedient and indulges her sensuality, offering her (sexual) treasure in return for the 'forbidden fruits'. Subsequently, Lizzie comes to the rescue, brave, loyal and loving, prepared to risk her own life in order to save her sister: 'Life out of death, / That night long Lizzie watch'd by her, / Counted her pulse's flagging stir, / Felt for her breath...' Yet Lizzie's sacrific for her sister is passive. She does not fight the goblins but merely stands motionless and silent, allowing them to assult her before she goes home to her sister: ' to offer herself as almost a sacramental meal.'
Gilbert and Gubar suggest various religious associations, for Lizzie saves Laura just as Christ saves Man, both are made pure and are welcomed to enter heaven - or marriage and motherhood in the case of the sisters. However, there is a sharp contrast between the message imparted by the Bible and that of the poem: 'Goblin Market', with its evil and mercantile little men and its innocent, high-minded women, suggests that men hurt while women redeem.' Gilbert and Gubar point out the traditional nature of connections between female pleasure and female power, and between female sexuality and female speech.
Guilt in the female consciousness
They explain that Victorian woman was respected for her 'blameless sexual life', especially since intellectuality in women was feared because it was accompanied by the curse of uncontrollable sexual desires. 'That genius and sexuality are diseases in women, diseases akin to madness, is implied in 'Goblin Market' both by Laura's illness the story of Jeanie.' Jeanie, who preceded Laura, became ill and died, having partaken of the goblins' fare. Jeanie was cursed with death, her punishment for succumbing to temptation, a fate that would have destroyed Laura had Lizzie not redeemed her. Finally, Gibert and Gubar describe the woman-poet as abandoned by her muse for failing to '...suffer and renounce the self-gratifications of art and sensuality.' This interpretation of 'Goblin Market' presents guilt as an integral part of female consciousness, and only renunciation of artistic endeavour provides redemption, for at the end of the poem, Laura and Lizzie are both married and caring for their daughters.
Kaplan, in Sea Changes, summarises the difficulties inherent in attempting to disentangle the poem's meaning in an historical context with how it might be read by a critic. 'Most simply, I suppose 'Goblin Market' can be seen as a comical-tragical view of the erotic from the women's position, with conscious and unconscious elements inextricably mingled.' It is not difficult to find many associations for all of the above analyses within the confines of this long poem. Which are more relevant is probably a matter for individual, subjective judgement. It seems likely that Christina Rossetti, in her statement that the poem is merely a fairy tale, is either protecting herself or performing an act of displacement, forced upon her by her natural desires and the restrictions and limitations of her time.
To My Mother on the Anniversary of her Birth, April 27, 1842, by Christina Rossetti, privately printed at G. Polidari's, London, 1842
'Rossetti, Christina (Georgina)' Cambridge Guide to Literature in English (ed) Ian Ousby, Cambridge University Press, Cambrdige, 1993
Sea Changes, Essays on Culture and Feminism, by Cora Kaplan, Verso, London, 1986
'The Aesthetics of Renunciation', The Madwoman in the Attic, by Sandra M. Gilbert and Susan Gubar, Yale University Press, New Haven and London, 1979.
'Goblin Market', The Complete Poems of Christina Rossetti, A Variorum Edition, (ed) R.W.Crump, Louisiana State University Press, Baton Rouge and London, 1979

No comments:

Post a Comment